An investigation is underway into possible voter fraud in the Republican primary for New York City Council District 47 after three absentee ballots - that News 12's aware of - raised red flags — including two votes cast by deceased individuals and one by an 87-year-old man whose son says he never participated.
The Brooklyn District Attorney’s Office has taken over the case and confirms it is actively investigating. Officials with the Board of Elections say 22 paper ballots have already been invalidated due to suspected fraud.
One of the invalid ballots belonged to William Allen, who, according to his son, Justin Allen, made it clear he did not want to vote in the Republican primary.
“My mother and I ripped it apart about a week before the election because he made clear he didn’t want to participate in the Republican primary,” Allen said. “Your vote is your choice. And if you choose not to vote, that’s also your choice. So nobody should take that away from you. They took that away from my father."
The initial results showed George Saranatopoulos as the winner of the Republican primary, but with ballots now under scrutiny, a recount is underway. Those results are expected tomorrow.
Saranatopoulos is accusing his opponent, Richie Barsamian — chairman of the Brooklyn Republican Party — of influencing the election process through his ability to appointment people to the Board of Elections.
“That falls squarely on Richie Barsamian,” he told News 12.
Barsamian denies any involvement, telling News 12 in a phone interview:
“That’s not true. That’s not correct. Everyone at the BOE was appointed long before I became chairman. I have no knowledge and no involvement whatsoever with anything connected to this race and anything that is incorrect from the BOE. Period. End of story.”
Meanwhile, Democratic candidate Kayla Santosuosso says the controversy has broader consequences for public trust in elections.
“I feel like it discourages participation,” Santosuosso said. “It makes people believe that the system can’t be trusted, and we just simply can’t afford that in our local elections.”
The Brooklyn DA’s office declined to comment further on the active investigation.
The Board of Elections is expected to announce who will officially take the Republican nomination for District 47 following the final recount.