The Macy's Backstage on Fordham Place is listed as one of 61 stores to close in the first quarter of the year.
It's currently listed as underperforming. Shoppers in Fordham were left shocked by the news.
"It was closer to my house, and it was easier for me to get to," said customer Sofia Ramos.
Macy's says Backstage store clearances will start in February and will run for around six weeks.
For a full list of the Macy’s locations set to close,
click here.