More Stories






Middletown head football coach resigns following playoff disqualification
Middletown High School head football coach Tim Strenfel has resigned following the team’s controversial disqualification from the playoffs over an ineligible player, sources confirmed to News 12.
Strenfel, who has led the Middies for nearly a decade, stepped down just days after the district’s unsuccessful court battle to get the team reinstated in the postseason.
The team had completed its first undefeated regular season in 65 years before its championship hopes were dashed by an eligibility violation involving a player who participated in Middletown’s Nov. 6 playoff victory over Valley Central.
The district previously acknowledged that the mistake was made by adults, not the student-athletes, and argued that the punishment was disproportionate to the violation.
Following Middletown’s disqualification on Nov. 9, Valley Central was selected to take its place in the Section IX Class AA championship against Newburgh Free Academy.
Middletown challenged the disqualification through the athletic appeals process before taking the matter to Orange County Supreme Court on Nov. 13. Following a nearly two-hour hearing, the district withdrew its petition after the judge indicated she would not grant the requested relief.
Valley Central went on to defeat Newburgh 16-6 on Nov. 14, winning its first Section IX Class AA championship.
Photo Credit: Valley Central School District
Middletown Superintendent Amy Creeden declined to comment on Strenfel’s resignation but directed News 12 to a Nov. 17 letter posted on the district’s website outlining the district’s next steps.
In that letter, Creeden announced a full investigation led by the district’s legal team to determine what went wrong, who was responsible for the decisions made and what changes are needed to prevent similar incidents.
“Taking responsibility as a district is not enough. There must also be accountability,” Creeden wrote.
The district says it will share changes to its procedures and oversight following the investigation. Creeden also announced plans to recognize the football players and cheerleaders for their historic season, beginning with Middletown’s tree-lighting ceremony and parade on Nov. 27. Additional celebrations are being planned with input from the athletes.
Meanwhile, Valley Central Superintendent Evette Avila praised her team’s perseverance in a statement to News 12 following the championship victory.
“As a district, we are so proud of our football team and its coaching staff. These Vikings never gave up, even when things got tough on and off the field. They showed true character, sportsmanship and VC Pride and have represented our district and this community well every step of the way. Best of all, the season isn’t over. We’re excited for our student-athletes and community to keep their journey going.”
Valley Central is now advancing to the state playoffs, with its next game scheduled for Nov. 21.
News 12 is continuing to seek additional information from the Middletown school district about Strenfel’s resignation and the ongoing investigation.