Seven-year-old Jor'dynn Duncan was remembered as a child whose smile could light up a room. But prosecutors now allege the little girl endured horrific abuse and was tortured and killed in December of last year by the very adults entrusted with her care.

As investigators continue building their case, Jor'dynn’s death is reigniting painful questions about whether warning signs were missed by the systems designed to protect vulnerable children.

“Lots of different systems touched this child’s life,” said Suffolk County Legislator Rebecca Sanin, a Democrat from Huntington Station. “The court system, the school system, child protective services. And we have to look back and figure out what went wrong.”

The tragedy has drawn comparisons to the 2020 death of 8-year-old Thomas Valva, who died of hypothermia after authorities said he was forced to sleep in an unheated garage during freezing temperatures. Public outrage over Valva’s death exposed serious deficiencies within Suffolk County Child Protective Services, including excessive caseloads and staffing shortages.

In response, Suffolk County launched a public website on Dec. 19, 2023, intended to track CPS caseloads and improve transparency. But records show the site was last updated just eight days later, on Dec. 27, 2023, and now appears blank.

County leaders later announced sweeping reforms to CPS in 2024, pledging to hire additional caseworkers, strengthen employee training and improve oversight procedures.

Seeking answers about whether those reforms were effective, News 12 visited the Suffolk County executive’s office Thursday. The county executive did not speak publicly about the case.

Details surrounding Jor'dynn’s life before her death are also raising alarms.

According to officials, the child missed 40 days of school between January and June of 2025. School officials said they are cooperating with law enforcement but declined to say whether those absences were ever reported to Child Protective Services.

Sanin said the warning signs appear difficult to ignore.

“She missed 40 days of school, the injuries that were described on her body - these are things that should have been picked up somewhere,” Sanin said.