The jury of six men and six women sent six notes to the court Friday requesting to review specific evidence and testimony. They asked to see two short clips of a 2019 police interview with Holley, during which Megan McDonald's cellphone was mentioned.


Jury zeros in on cellphone as deliberations in Ed Holley murder trial extend into next week

The jury asked for a read-back of jury instructions, certain evidence photos and DNA reports, all of which were provided.

Jury in Ed Holley murder trial asks judge how to deliberate, whether they can use Google in jury room

DiCaprio said he was in the common area of the medical unit at the Orange County Jail when he heard Holley tell another inmate that he beat his ex-girlfriend Megan McDonald in her car in the Town of Wallkill in March 2003.

Jurors in Ed Holley murder trial review testimony of jail informant who aided prosecutors in multiple previous cases

Jurors wrapped up their third day of deliberations Tuesday afternoon at the Orange County Courthouse in Goshen, and are expected to resume deliberations Wednesday morning into whether to convict Holley of murdering Megan McDonald in March 2003.

5 to 7 split: Jury in Ed Holley murder trial told to keep deliberating after note telling judge they are 'deadlocked'

The court reporter finished most of the read-back on Monday of retired state police investigator John Ramos, who was the lead investigator for the first year following Megan McDonald's murder in March 2003.

Jury requests read back of 190 pages of testimony on first full day of Edward Holley murder trial deliberations

Town Supervisor Gil Piaquadio said the town fought the residents in court for years, even seeking to strike down parts of the state's voting rights act, to minimize change and preserve most of the town's at-large voting system.

Ad Choices

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Privacy Manager